Szczepanik Research Group

Department of Theoretical Chemistry
Faculty of Chemistry, Jagiellonian University
Gronostajowa 2, 30-387 Krakow, Poland
Tel: (+48) 12 686 23 90
E-mail: dariusz.szczepanik@uj.edu.pl

HOME      PROJECTS      PUBLICATIONS      runEDDB      X

About EDDB       Download       Tutorials       Manual



◼ Tutorial 6 — π-Reorganization in a hydrogen-bonded guanine quartet

Four guanines, eight hydrogen bonds, one planar ring. Does hydrogen bonding change the π-system of each guanine, and where? The differential BDF map of Tutorial 5 answers it again — with a new twist: the reference is a single molecule, the complex holds four, and only one of them can be aligned at a time.

What you will learn
  • Mapping the π-reorganization that accompanies hydrogen bonding with a differential BDFπ map (--export-cube dbdf).
  • Comparing a complex with one of its monomers: what the map shows inside and outside the reference box.
  • Using symmetry to assemble the full map, and the per-atom π-populations to read it.

Before you start

A guanine quartet (G-quartet) is a planar, cyclic assembly of four guanines — the building block of G-quadruplex DNA. Each guanine donates two hydrogen bonds from its Watson–Crick edge (N1–H and N2–H) to one neighbour, and accepts two at its Hoogsteen edge (O6 and N7) from the other: eight hydrogen bonds in all, N1–H···O6 and N2–H···N7. The quartet studied here has four-fold (C4h) symmetry, so all four guanines are equivalent.


Figure 1. The G-quartet: four guanines held by eight N–H···O and N–H···N hydrogen bonds. The π-conjugated lone pairs are drawn as dots.

You need two geometry files: G.xyz, an isolated guanine, and G4.xyz, the quartet. In G4.xyz the four guanines are listed as consecutive blocks of 16 atoms, each in the same order as G.xyz.

💾 G.xyz💾 G4.xyz

Our aim is a differential map that shows how the π-structure of each guanine changes when the quartet forms:

ΔBDFπ = BDFπ(G4) − BDFπ(G)

Guanine has 14 π-electrons: eight from four double bonds and six from three π-conjugated lone pairs (Figure 1). The quartet has 56. Hence there are 7 π-NOBDs for the monomer and 28 for the quartet.


Part 1 — The reference: BDFπ of an isolated guanine

 terminal
$ runEDDB -i G.xyz -s 1:7 --export-cube bdf --table npa,nobd -c 150 > G.log
 G.log
  ⋯ banner, stage lines and NPA table omitted ⋯
  │            NATURAL ORBITALS FOR BOND DELOCALIZATION (NOBD) IN NVB BASIS            │
  └────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
    Index  Sel   Occupancy    s (l=0)  %s    p (l=1)  %p    d (l=2)  %d    f (l=3)  %f
   ─────── ───   ═════════   ───────── ───  ───────── ───  ───────── ───  ───────── ───
         1  *      1.54327     0.00000  0     1.54327 100    0.00000  0     0.00000  0 
         2  *      1.37796     0.00000  0     1.37796 100    0.00000  0     0.00000  0 
         3  *      1.12110     0.00000  0     1.12110 100    0.00000  0     0.00000  0 
         4  *      1.05821     0.00000  0     1.05821 100    0.00000  0     0.00000  0 
         5  *      1.03841     0.00000  0     1.03841 100    0.00000  0     0.00000  0 
         6  *      0.65612     0.00000  0     0.65612 100    0.00000  0     0.00000  0 
         7  *      0.62778     0.00000  0     0.62778 100    0.00000  0     0.00000  0 
         8         0.16805     0.02856  17    0.13949  83    0.00000  0     0.00000  0 
         9         0.15964     0.00147  1     0.15817  99    0.00000  0     0.00000  0 
        10         0.14735     0.03402  23    0.11333  77    0.00000  0     0.00000  0 
  ⋯ NOBDs 11–40 omitted ⋯

▶ Printing summary of EDDB calculations:

        Total   ED_G population:           14.00000    per atom:     0.87500
        Total EDLB_G population:            6.57714    per atom:     0.41107
        Total EDDB_G population:            7.42286    per atom:     0.46393

▶ Calculation completed on 2026-10-29. Total time: 4s.

The summary confirms the choice: Total ED_G = 14.000.


Figure 2. BDFπ of isolated guanine, isosurface 0.015. Turquoise: BDFπ > 0 (delocalized bonding dominates); yellow: BDFπ < 0 (localized electrons).

A delocalized domain runs from C2 through N3 and C4 to C5, while the carbonyl group and the lone pair of the amino nitrogen are localized. About 53 % of the π-electrons are delocalized (Total EDDB_G 7.423 of 14.000 e).


Part 2 — BDFπ of the quartet

 terminal
$ runEDDB -i G4.xyz -s 1:28 --export-cube bdf --table npa,nobd -c 150 > G4.log

In the NOBD table the 28 π-NOBDs arrive as seven near-degenerate quartets, one member per guanine (1.609, 1.532, 1.205, 1.103, 1.007, 0.777, 0.737), followed by a sharp gap to NOBD 29 at 0.176:

 G4.log
  ⋯ banner, stage lines and NPA table omitted ⋯
  │            NATURAL ORBITALS FOR BOND DELOCALIZATION (NOBD) IN NVB BASIS            │
  └────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
    Index  Sel   Occupancy    s (l=0)  %s    p (l=1)  %p    d (l=2)  %d    f (l=3)  %f
   ─────── ───   ═════════   ───────── ───  ───────── ───  ───────── ───  ───────── ───
  ⋯ NOBDs 1–24 omitted ⋯
        25  *      0.73723     0.00000  0     0.73723 100    0.00000  0     0.00000  0 
        26  *      0.73675     0.00000  0     0.73675 100    0.00000  0     0.00000  0 
        27  *      0.73675     0.00000  0     0.73675 100    0.00000  0     0.00000  0 
        28  *      0.73626     0.00000  0     0.73626 100    0.00000  0     0.00000  0 
        29         0.17581     0.03693  21    0.13888  79    0.00000  0     0.00000  0 
        30         0.17571     0.03735  21    0.13837  79    0.00000  0     0.00000  0 
        31         0.17571     0.03735  21    0.13837  79    0.00000  0     0.00000  0 
  ⋯ NOBDs 32–160 omitted ⋯

▶ Printing summary of EDDB calculations:

        Total   ED_G population:           56.00000    per atom:     0.87500
        Total EDLB_G population:           24.11777    per atom:     0.37684
        Total EDDB_G population:           31.88223    per atom:     0.49816

▶ Calculation completed on 2026-10-29. Total time: 12s.


Figure 3. BDFπ of the guanine quartet, isosurface 0.015.

At first sight each guanine keeps the pattern of the isolated molecule. The difference shows in the EDDB_G numbers: the delocalized fraction rises from 53.0 % in guanine to 56.9 % in the quartet (31.882 / 4 − 7.423 = +0.548 e per guanine). The changes are too subtle to read by comparing Figures 2 and 3 by eye. That is what the differential map is for.


Part 3 — The differential ΔBDFπ map

We subtract the reference from the quartet, point by point on the reference grid. Positive regions gained delocalization on forming the quartet; negative regions became more localized.

 terminal
$ runEDDB -i G4.xyz -s 1:28 --export-cube dbdf --cube-ref G.BDF_G.cube --cube-align 1:16 > G4d.log
 G4d.log
  ⋯ banner and stage lines omitted ⋯
▶ Exporting differential BDF to G4.DBDF_G.cube...
    Alignment atoms (--cube-align):    16
    RMSD after rigid alignment:           0.02582 Angstrom
    Max residual displacement:            0.05418 Angstrom
    (arbitrary translation + rotation removed; residual = internal deformation)

  WARNING: only 16 of 64 selected (--fragment / --pathway) atoms overlap the reference geometry.
           --export-cube dbdf subtracts point-by-point, so the analysed region must
           share ONE coordinate frame with the reference. Align them BEFORE the
           QM single-point (freeze the common fragment's coordinates); runEDDB
           does not rotate the wavefunction. For a large system that reorganizes
           elsewhere, restrict to the conserved region with --fragment / --pathway.
           The dBDF map below is likely meaningless as it stands.
                                    12s
⚠ The warning is expected here. runEDDB checks how many of the analysed atoms overlap the reference geometry. Only one guanine (16 of 64 atoms) can lie on top of the single reference molecule, so the program warns that the map as a whole is not a clean difference. That is exactly the situation described below: the map is meaningful for the aligned guanine and only there. The RMSD of 0.026 Å says that the aligned guanine itself barely deforms in the quartet.


Figure 4. The raw ΔBDFπ map, isosurface ±0.010. Green: ΔBDFπ > 0; orange: ΔBDFπ < 0. Only the guanine in the red box — the one aligned onto the reference — carries a meaningful difference.

The reference holds a single isolated guanine, superimposed on the first guanine of the quartet, so nothing is subtracted at the positions of the other three: the partially visible lobes there are their raw BDFπ in the quartet. And because the map exists only inside the grid box of the monomer, those raw lobes are cut off at the box edge. The only part of the map to read is inside the red box.


Part 4 — The full map from symmetry

All four guanines are equivalent, so the map of the aligned guanine represents the other three. Rotating it by 90°, 180° and 270° about the four-fold axis gives the full ΔBDFπ map:


Figure 5. ΔBDFπ for the full quartet, assembled from the aligned guanine by four-fold rotation. Isosurface ±0.010.

Complexes without symmetry. Compute one differential map per monomer and combine them. Since --cube-align requires the same index and element in both files, reorder the complex so that the monomer of interest occupies the first block of atoms, in the order of its reference file, and use the matching isolated monomer as the reference.

Part 5 — π-Cloud polarization

The NPA tables of G.log and G4.log give the change of the π-population of every atom, ΔED_G = ED_G(G4) − ED_G(G):


Figure 6. Change in π-electron population on forming the quartet, ΔED_G. Red: π-density lost; blue: gained.

The four largest changes are on the four atoms that take part in hydrogen bonding. The donor nitrogens lose π-density (N1 −0.047 e, N2 −0.050 e) and the acceptors gain it (O6 +0.052 e, N7 +0.034 e): π-density moves from the Watson–Crick edge of each guanine to its Hoogsteen edge. Each guanine still holds exactly 14.000 π-electrons, so the density is redistributed within each guanine, not transferred between them.

Table 1. Changes per guanine on forming the quartet, from the NPA tables of G.log and G4.log. Shaded rows are the hydrogen-bonding atoms; the atom index in the .xyz files is given in brackets. Atom numbering in Figure 7.

atomrole in the quartetΔED_GΔEDDB_GΔBDF lobe
N1 (3)H-bond donor (N1–H···O6)−0.047+0.054green
N2, amine (1)H-bond donor (N2–H···N7)−0.050+0.068green
O6 (2)H-bond acceptor+0.052+0.111green
N7 (11)H-bond acceptor+0.034+0.025—
C2 (4)−0.014+0.037green
N3 (5)+0.011+0.137green
C4 (6)−0.010+0.019—
C5 (7)+0.012+0.035—
C6 (8)−0.002+0.078green
C8 (10)+0.006+0.016—
N9 (9)+0.006−0.031orange
per guanine0.000+0.548


Figure 7. Atom numbering of guanine.


Part 6 — Resonance interpretation


Figure 8. Top: the hydrogen-bond pattern of the quartet. Bottom: resonance structures that explain the changes in delocalization and in the atomic π-populations.

The second and third structures carry the lone pairs of N1 and of the amino nitrogen N2 onto O6. They account for the donors losing π-density, O6 gaining it, and the C6=O6 bond becoming more delocalized — the green dumbbell on the carbonyl in Figure 5. Hydrogen bonding at the donor edge and at O6 favours exactly these charge-separated forms.

The fourth structure places the negative charge on N7, through a charge transfer from N9. Why then does the N9 lone pair become slightly more localized (the orange lobe in Figure 5)? Because this resonance competes with the cyclic delocalization in the only aromatic ring of guanine, the imidazole ring. Its CDI (see Tutorial 1 and Tutorial 2) is lower in the quartet than in the isolated guanine. Run the pathway analysis for the five-membered ring (atoms 6-7-11-10-9 of the first guanine) in both files:

 terminal
$ runEDDB -i G.xyz  -p 6-7-11-10-9-6 -a -q
$ runEDDB -i G4.xyz -p 6-7-11-10-9-6 -a -q

The CDI drops from 0.410 (G) to 0.377 (G4), while the six-membered ring (-p 3-4-5-6-7-8-3) goes the other way, from 0.157 to 0.207. The cyclic delocalization of the imidazole ring also runs through resonance structures with charge transfer from the N9 lone pair, so the overall delocalization of that lone pair can decrease even though one single contributor grows.

Why -a and not -s here? A pathway run (-p) computes its own NOBDs for the selected atoms, so the indices 1:7 and 1:28 of the global runs mean different orbitals there. Let -a pick the π-NOBDs of the ring.

How much this π-reorganization contributes to the strength of the hydrogen bonds is a separate question. Energy decomposition analyses of G-quartets attribute their cooperativity mainly to σ donor–acceptor interactions, with only a small π contribution [C. Fonseca Guerra, H. Zijlstra, G. Paragi, F. M. Bickelhaupt, Chem. Eur. J. 2011, 17, 12612]. The differential map shows clearly that a π-response exists; it does not by itself measure its energetic weight.


What to try next

Where to go next. Tutorial 7 turns from delocalization to the magnetic response: NICS, ring and bond currents of phenalenyl, from a bare geometry to a full NMR job. The Maps & files page of the Manual describes differential maps in full.

Tutorial prepared by Paweł Wieczorkiewicz.


 

HOME      PROJECTS      PUBLICATIONS      runEDDB      X

About EDDB       Download       Tutorials       Manual